Concentrix CVG Customer Service Management Group, Inc., JD-77-26, 12-CA-345633 (ALJ Decision)
An administrative law judge found that Concentrix unlawfully told a remote customer service representative to take his union ideas to the company's People Solutions department. The judge also found that several confidentiality and communications rules were overbroad. Other allegations were dismissed, including those challenging the company's solicitation policy and the employee's written counseling.
The employee posted in a work Teams chat that coworkers "would need to unionize to get to know each other and change the policy." His team leader told him to keep that out of the chat, and she directed him to People Solutions instead. The judge found the solicitation policy lawful under Caesars Entertainment, which returned to the Register Guard standard. Under that standard employees have no right to use employer IT systems for Section 7 purposes, absent a rare showing that they lack other reasonable means of communicating. Employees here could and did exchange personal contact information, so they had adequate alternatives. The policy's reference to "labor" organizations was not discriminatory because it bars solicitation for any organization. Because the policy was lawful, directing the employee to stop urging unionization in the chat was lawful too. The judge also found, however, that the instruction to take union ideas to People Solutions reasonably suggested that employees must clear union discussions with management, which violated Section 8(a)(1).
Applying Stericycle, the judge found five rules unlawful because employees could reasonably read them to restrict discussion of wages and working conditions, and the company did not show that narrower rules would not serve its interests:
The definition of proprietary information covering employee compensation and performance levels.
The requirement to get company authorization before publishing material.
The Home Agent Agreement provision treating all company emails and texts as confidential.
The social networking policy.
The policy on communicating with external audiences.
The judge upheld the "Using Technology Appropriately" rule because its ban on unauthorized solicitation mirrors the lawful solicitation policy. The judge declined the company's request to recommend overturning Stericycle, noting that this is outside an administrative law judge's role. The recommended order requires the company to rescind or revise the unlawful rules, notify employees that they need not discuss unions only with People Solutions, and post, text, and mail a notice.
Significant Cases Cited
Caesars Entertainment d/b/a Rio All-Suites Hotel and Casino, 368 NLRB No. 143 (2019): Employers may generally restrict employee use of their IT equipment for Section 7 purposes, subject to a rare exception where it is the only reasonable means of communication, and it overruled Purple Communications.
Register Guard, 351 NLRB 1110 (2007): Employees have no statutory right to use employer equipment, including IT resources, for Section 7 purposes.
Stericycle, Inc., 372 NLRB No. 113 (2023): Facially neutral work rules are presumptively unlawful if a reasonable employee could read them to restrict Section 7 rights, unless the employer proves a legitimate and substantial interest that a narrower rule could not serve.
Wright Line, 251 NLRB 1083 (1980): Sets the burden-shifting framework for deciding whether discipline was motivated by protected activity.
Meyers Industries, 268 NLRB 493 (1984): Concerted activity includes action taken with or on behalf of other employees, or bringing truly group complaints to management.
unWired Broadband, Inc., JD(SF)-19-26, 32-CA-376939 (ALJ Decision)
An administrative law judge found that UnWired Broadband, LLC unlawfully refused to bargain with the Communication Workers of America (CWA) for a first contract and failed to provide requested information. The judge concluded that by starting to bargain after the union was certified, the employer gave up its right to contest the certification.
After the Regional Director certified the CWA on September 25, 2025, UnWired did not immediately refuse to bargain in order to test the certification. It responded to the union's information request, scheduled a session, and met on November 14, where the union presented 17 contract proposals and the parties discussed them. UnWired then filed a request for review of the certification on November 21 and cancelled the December sessions, saying it would not bargain until the Board ruled. The judge explained that an employer may either bargain or challenge a certification but cannot do both, and that bargaining waives the challenge. He rejected the claim that November 14 was only a "meet and greet," crediting the parties' communications and bargaining notes, and discrediting the employer's witness.
The judge also rejected the argument that the employer never dealt with the certified representative. The CWA is the certified representative, and its district staff representative made the bargaining demands and information requests. Local 9333 officials took part on the CWA's behalf, and the employer never objected. The judge held that continued discussions with the union about discipline and other workplace matters did not cure the violation, because an employer cannot pick which parts of the bargaining relationship to honor. The November 21 information request concerned unit employees and was presumptively relevant. Because the employer had waived its challenge, its pending request for review was no defense to the failure to provide that information.
The judge recommended an order requiring UnWired to bargain on request, provide the information, and post a notice. The one-year certification period will run from the date good-faith bargaining resumes. He found an affirmative bargaining order warranted because employees lost about nine months of first-contract bargaining. Allegations in a related case were dismissed after a non-Board settlement.
Significant Cases Cited
Technicolor Government Services, Inc. v. NLRB, 739 F.2d 323 (8th Cir. 1984): Once an employer recognizes a union and negotiates with it, the employer waives any objection to the validity of the certification.
Terrace Gardens Plaza, Inc. v. NLRB, 91 F.3d 222 (D.C. Cir. 1996): After certification, an employer may either bargain or challenge the certification, but may not do both at once.
Finerty v. NLRB, 113 F.3d 1288 (D.C. Cir. 1997): CWA districts are administrative units of the international union, which is the certified bargaining representative, not separate locals.
T-Mobile USA, 365 NLRB 175 (2017): An employer that recognizes a union must fulfill all aspects of its bargaining obligations and may not selectively bargain.
Teachers College, Columbia University, 365 NLRB 824 (2017): Information about bargaining unit employees is presumptively relevant and must be furnished to the union.
Ge Appliances, a Haier Company, JD-76-26, 09-CA-351781 (ALJ Decision)
An administrative law judge dismissed the complaint in its entirety, finding that the General Counsel did not prove that GE Appliances threatened a union steward with reassignment or transferred him in retaliation for his union activity.
Jeff Warren, a second shift maintenance technician and union steward, was moved from the P2/P3 lines to the QS line the day after he refused his supervisor's instruction to tell another employee where to work. Warren told the supervisor that directing employees was management's job and that his role was to represent them. The judge fully credited Warren's account but found no testimony that the supervisor conditioned a transfer on compliance. The supervisor simply repeated the question twice and then announced the reassignment. The threat allegation therefore failed.
On the transfer, the judge applied the Wright Line framework. Knowledge of Warren's union activity was established because the supervisor knew of it and had input into the decision, so his knowledge was imputed to the maintenance director who made the call. The judge also found the transfer was an adverse action, since the QS line was more difficult and less desirable even though Warren's shift, building, and hours did not change. The claim failed on animus. The General Counsel offered little evidence of a contentious relationship between Warren and the supervisor, and the judge credited testimony that the decision was made over time by several layers of management in response to a plant-wide cost-cutting directive. The stated reasons were a long-vacant QS technician position covered by overtime employees handing off mid-shift, and Warren's assignment to a line that no longer ran production for most of his shift. Because the decision predated the July 31 exchange, timing did not support an inference of retaliation. The judge found no pretext, no similarly situated employee treated differently, and no departure from past practice. Warren was told the move was temporary and declined other offered positions. The judge also noted that the continuing P2/P3 work now done on overtime did not show the explanation was false.
Significant Cases Cited
Wright Line, 251 NLRB 1083 (1980): Sets the burden-shifting framework requiring the General Counsel to show protected activity, employer knowledge, and animus before the employer must prove it would have taken the same action regardless.
NLRB v. Transportation Management Corp., 462 U.S. 393 (1983): The Supreme Court approved the Wright Line burden-shifting test as a reasonable reading of the NLRA.
Intertape Polymer Corp., 372 NLRB No. 133 (2023): Restates the elements of a retaliation claim and allows animus to be inferred from circumstantial evidence such as timing, pretext, and disparate treatment.
Springfield Air Center, 311 NLRB 1151 (1993): Knowledge of protected activity is imputed to decision makers when the person with knowledge had at least some input into the decision.
River City Asphalt, 372 NLRB No. 87 (2023): A reassignment can be an adverse action even without loss of pay when employees credibly show the new assignment is less desirable.
Yarde Metals, Inc., 01-RC-377065 (Regional Election Decision)
The Regional Director directed elections in two separate units sought by Teamsters Local 671: about 30 CDL drivers and 13 maintenance employees at the Employer's Southington, Connecticut facility. The Employer argued that both groups share an overwhelming community of interest with roughly 150 warehouse employees, so that only a wall-to-wall unit would be appropriate. The Regional Director rejected that argument because the Employer did not carry its burden.
Applying American Steel Construction, Inc., which reinstated the Specialty Healthcare framework, the Regional Director found both petitioned-for units internally cohesive and readily identifiable. Each is its own department with separate supervision, and no party disputed that. The question was whether the units were sufficiently distinct. Under that test, the party seeking a larger unit must show an overwhelming community of interest with the excluded employees, meaning only minimal differences from a collective-bargaining perspective. Some overlapping interests do not defeat a smaller unit, even if a larger one would also be appropriate.
Several factors favored the petitioned-for units. Drivers must hold commercial licenses, meet experience and DOT physical requirements, and follow DOT rules. Maintenance employees alone repair equipment. Drivers rarely interact with warehouse employees, and the three groups have separate supervision. Temporary interchange is limited, and permanent transfers carry less weight. Other factors favored the Employer: warehouse loading and maintenance contact show some functional integration, and all employees share benefits, pay scales, uniforms, hiring, orientation, and facilities. The Regional Director found these overlaps did not outweigh the distinctions.
The Employer also argued in its brief that third shift loaders must be added to the drivers' unit and warehouse associates to the maintenance unit. That argument was not raised earlier, and it failed for the same reason. The drivers' unit includes loader/drivers but excludes warehouse employees and employees not required to hold a CDL. Elections will be held at the Employer's facility, and a request for review may be filed with the Board.
Significant Cases Cited
American Steel Construction, Inc., 372 NLRB No. 23 (2022): Reinstated the Specialty Healthcare standard, under which a party arguing for a larger unit must show an overwhelming community of interest with the excluded employees.
Specialty Healthcare & Rehabilitation Center of Mobile, 357 NLRB 934 (2011): Established the overwhelming community of interest test for evaluating petitioned-for units that subdivide employee classifications.
PCC Structurals, Inc., 365 NLRB No. 160 (2017): Overruled Specialty Healthcare, before being itself overruled by American Steel.
Home Depot USA, Inc., 331 NLRB 1289 (2000): Found a unit of drivers appropriate despite excluding other employees in the same department.
WideOpenWest Illinois, LLC, 371 NLRB No. 107 (2022): Explained that functional integration exists only when employees must work together and depend on one another to accomplish their tasks.
Doctors Hospital of Manteca, Inc. D/B/a Doctors Hospital of Manteca, 32-RC-396733 (Regional Election Decision)
The Regional Director directed an Armour-Globe self-determination election allowing about 27 surgical services employees at Doctors Hospital of Manteca to vote on joining an existing multi-facility bargaining unit represented by SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West. The petitioned-for group includes surgical technologists, anesthesia technologists, sterile processing technologists, and endoscopy technologists. The Employer argued the petition should be dismissed because the existing unit is nonconforming under the Board's Health Care Rule and the employees lack a community of interest with it.
The Regional Director first found the petitioned-for employees are a distinct, identifiable voting group, since they work in one department, in the same operating room area, and under the Director of Surgical Services. On community of interest, the Regional Director relied primarily on two grounds. First, under St. Vincent Charity Medical Center, adding classifications to a nonconforming unit does not violate the Health Care Rule, and employees in the same Health Care Rule category as existing unit members have a presumptive community of interest. The petitioned-for employees are technical or nonprofessional, and the existing unit includes both. Second, the unit already includes the same classifications at other Tenet hospitals, and the Employer offered no evidence that those jobs differ.
In the alternative, the traditional factors also supported inclusion. Training requirements resembled those of unit emergency department technicians, and job functions overlapped or paralleled those of emergency department technicians and housekeeping employees. The petitioned-for employees had regular contact with housekeeping staff, some functional integration, similar hourly pay and uniforms, and the same hospital-wide orientation. Bargaining history favored inclusion because the contract covers these classifications elsewhere. Common supervision and departmental organization were neutral given the existing unit's diversity, and the lack of interchange weighed against a community of interest. The petitioned-for employees need share a community of interest only with part of the existing unit.
The election is set for November 19, 2026, at the hospital. If a majority votes for the Petitioner, the employees will join the existing unit. The Employer must file its voter list by November 17, 2026. Review may be requested from the Board, but doing so does not stay the election unless the Board orders it.
Significant Cases Cited
Warner-Lambert Co., 298 NLRB 993 (1990): An Armour-Globe election is the proper method for adding unrepresented employees to an existing unit, based on community of interest and whether the group is a distinct, identifiable segment.
St. Vincent Charity Medical Center, 357 NLRB 854 (2011): A self-determination election to add classifications to a nonconforming unit does not violate the Health Care Rule, and same-category employees share a presumptive community of interest.
Rush University Medical Center v. NLRB, 833 F.3d 202 (D.C. Cir. 2016): The Health Care Rule's limit on additional units does not apply to an Armour-Globe election, which adds employees to an existing unit.
United Operations, Inc., 338 NLRB 123 (2002): Sets out the factors the Board weighs in a community of interest analysis, with no single factor controlling.
Walt Disney Parks & Resorts, U.S., Inc., 373 NLRB No. 99 (2024): The diversity of an existing unit may be considered in self-determination cases and can reduce the weight of factors like separate supervision.

